Cookies on the New Scientist website

close
Our website uses cookies, which are small text files that are widely used in order to make websites work more effectively. To continue using our website and consent to the use of cookies, click away from this box or click 'Close'
Find out about our cookies and how to change them

SUBSCRIBE & SAVE 20% »

MANAGE MY ACCOUNT »

GIVE A GIFT »

Physics & Math

Log in

Email

Password

Remember me

Your login is case sensitive

I have forgotten my password

Register now

Activate my subscription

Institutional login

Athens login

close

My New Scientist

Home

News

In-Depth Articles

Opinion

Books & Art

Galleries

Topic Guides

Last Word

Subscribe

Dating

Look for Science Jobs

SPACE

TECH

ENVIRONMENT

HEALTH

LIFE

PHYSICS&MATH

SCIENCE IN SOCIETY

Cookies & Privacy

Home

|Physics & Math

|

News

Schrödinger's 'kittens' made in the lab from photons

18:42 24 July 2013

by

Katia Moskvitch, Moscow, Russia

For similar stories, visit the

Quantum World

Topic Guide

Erwin Schrödinger dreamed up the famous thought experiment about a cat that is both dead and alive to demonstrate the absurdity of applying quantum mechanics to ordinary objects. Now two teams have made the closest thing yet to a Schrödinger's cat in the lab – by connecting hundreds of millions of photons via the strange quantum property of entanglement.

"It's not the entanglement of something as big as a cat, but it's at least a kitten," says Seth Lloyd of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, a quantum physicist who was not involved in the work.

The results, which were presented on 23 July at the Second International Conference on Quantum Technologies, in Moscow, Russia, suggest that the rules of quantum mechanics may extend to much larger objects than we thought – and that this could have practical uses.

We know that quantum properties such as entanglement – the linking of the states of two objects – and superposition – the ability of something to be in two states at once – describe the behaviour of very small objects, but our experience tells us that these properties don't apply to large ones. Schrödinger's thought experiment emphasises this discrepancy.

If a cat is in a box with a radioactive atom that can decay to trigger the release of a poison from a flask, then the state of the cat and the state of the atom are entangled: if the radioactive atom decays, the cat dies. But according to quantum mechanics, the atom, a quantum object, can be in a superposition of decayed and not decayed states at the same time. And that means that the cat is also both alive and dead – though in the real world, this seems absurd.

No superposed cats

An apparent lack of cats – and other large objects – in such a superposition has led physicists to wonder where exactly the quantum realm ends, and why. "Is there a border between micro and macro, or does quantum mechanics apply on all scales?" asks Alexander Lvovsky, who works at the University of Calgary in Alberta, Canada, and the Russian Quantum Center in Moscow, which organised the conference.

Previous experiments aimed to answer this question by getting ever bigger objects to display quantum properties. For example, two 3-millimetre diamonds have been entangled, and a drum the size of a grain of sand has been caught obeying the uncertainty principle, which says you cannot simultaneously determine a quantum particle's exact position and momentum.

Lvovsky and colleagues wanted to mimic the Schrödinger's cat scenario more faithfully. They used a semi-transparent mirror to put a single photon into a mixture of two quantum states – one corresponding to the photon passing through the mirror, and the other corresponding to reflection. They then entangled the two states.

Next, the team used lasers to amplify one of the states, so that it was spread over hundreds of millions of photons. This beam was big enough to see in principle, though the frequency of the light was not in the visible range.

They then restored the light to its original one-photon state. Measurements confirmed that the entanglement had remained throughout the experiment – even though one state had been applied to a macroscopic system for a time.

Macro-micro link

The researchers say this represents the first entanglement between a microscopic and macroscopic object. Just as the atom in Schrödinger's thought experiment is linked with the cat, in Lvovsky's experiment, the state of a single photon is linked to the hundred-million-strong array.

"Our breakthrough has been that, so far, people have been able to build these superposition states containing only a few photons, and we've been able to do it with 160 million photons," says Lvovsky.

Meanwhile, Nicolas Gisin and his colleagues from the University of Geneva in Switzerland got similar results, but with a slightly different experimental set-up.

Lloyd suggests that macro-micro entanglement could be used to dramatically increase the accuracy of interferometers – devices that use entanglement to measure very small differences in length.

Both teams say that they are still far away from reproducing the experiment with a real cat. As Lvovsky points out, that would be "inhumane" anyway.

Journal references: Lvovsky: Nature Physics, DOI: 10.1038/nphys2682; Gisin: Nature Physics, DOI: 10.1038/nphys2681

63

Share on email
Share on gmail
Share on stumbleupon

If you would like to reuse any content from New Scientist, either in print or online, please contact the syndication department first for permission. New Scientist does not own rights to photos, but there are a variety of licensing options available for use of articles and graphics we own the copyright to.

Have your say

Only subscribers may leave comments on this article. Please log in.

email:

password:

Remember me

Only personal subscribers may leave comments on this article

Subscribe now to comment.

Congratulations On Pushing The Envelope!

Wed Jul 24 22:39:22 BST 2013 by Russ Otter

http://www.otterthink.com

Truly Congratulations on pushing beyond the molecule level. My concern is still how to actualize a living organism, such as a cat, or even a plant, as an entangled elementary particle? Particles, waves, molecules, and now your expansion of photons, have not been shown how they could entangle with life per se'. One is an amalgam of particles/waves, and the other is physical matter, that transcends the ethereal nature of atoms and molecules. However, in a big manner: You are forging in the right direction, but a measuring stick could clearly be the transition from wave/particle to multi-faceted non-ubiquitous matter. This latter construct, is of building blocks, of different elementary particles, but the photon expansion, is purely the same in construct. Something to consider, perhaps...

Still I believe your work is critically important, and expands on the truth and journey science affords us.

Again, Congratulations, and Thank You again for your work and the report, Russ

login and reply

report this comment

Very Nicely Written

Thu Jul 25 03:22:51 BST 2013 by Giampy

A lot of articles on these subject are either confusing or misrepresent reality, but I have to say that this article is very clear, simple and well written.

On the subject, i wonder if these results are enough to disprove theories like CST or GRW. I guess we'll see ...

login and reply

report this comment

All comments should respect the New Scientist House Rules. If you think a particular comment breaks these rules then please use the "Report" link in that comment to report it to us.

If you are having a technical problem posting a comment, please contact technical support.

63

Share on email
Share on gmail
Share on stumbleupon

A quantum object that meows? (Image: Ineke Kamps/Getty Images)

ADVERTISEMENT

More

Latest news

Light completely stopped for a record-breaking minute

09:00 25 July 2013

Using lasers and magnetic fields, the fastest thing in the universe, light, has been halted for a minute – the time it takes to make 20 round-trips to the moon

2D planet lander and suspended animation get NASA cash

16:15 23 July 2013

Paper-thin spacecraft and suspended animation for Mars trips are some of the weirder concepts backed by NASA

Particle puzzle: Honey, I shrunk the proton

16:00 22 July 2013

Curious goings-on at the heart of the atom may be pointing to a new force of nature

Neutrino shape-shift points to new physics

00:26 20 July 2013

A detector in Japan has for the first time seen neutrinos morph between two of their three flavours, offering new ways to probe interactions between matter and antimatter

see all related stories

More

Latest news

Google searches mined to uncover our true opinions

13:02 25 July 2013

What we search for on the web can be used, anonymously, to give a unique insight into what we are really worrying about

Zoologger: The pint-sized sabre-toothed opossum

12:15 25 July 2013

Cats with formidable canines roamed the Earth 11,000 years ago, but exactly how they used their teeth is a mystery. Could a small marsupial offer clues?

Light completely stopped for a record-breaking minute

09:00 25 July 2013

Using lasers and magnetic fields, the fastest thing in the universe, light, has been halted for a minute – the time it takes to make 20 round-trips to the moon

Feather-light sensors are as comfy as a second skin

22:12 24 July 2013

An ultrathin foil loaded with circuits promises virtually imperceptible medical sensors and flexible artificial skin for robots

see all latest news

Most read

Most commented

Huge methane belch in Arctic could cost $60 trillion

17th-century gadget gives up secrets to 3D printer

AI scores same as a 4-year-old in verbal IQ test

Blue wave of death caught on camera

Schrödinger's 'kittens' made in the lab from photons

Most read

Most commented

No evidence behind British cigarette pack decision

Black hole binge could test general relativity

Why UK's net porn filter will be tricky to enforce

Storm warning: The winds of climate change

Five things the royal baby knows about the world

FOLLOW US

Get editors' picks in your social streams

Share on facebookFacebook
Share on twitterTwitter
Share on linkedinLinkedin
Share on google_followGoogle
Share on pinterestPinterest

LATEST JOBS

Johnson & Johnson: SUPERVISOR, MANUFACTURING (2 positions) Job

Oakhurst Executive Selection Limited: Molecular and Cell Biology Sales Specialist – Cambridge/East Anglia

Johnson & Johnson: SENIOR QUALITY ENGINEER Job

Johnson & Johnson: SCIENTIFIC FELLOW - ENGINEERING Job

Celgene: Director, Supply Chain Job

This week's issue

Subscribe

For exclusive news and expert analysis, subscribe to New Scientist.

Gain full online access

Current issue content

Content of past issues

27 July 2013

ADVERTISEMENT

Back to top

Login

Email

Password

Remember me

Your login is case sensitive

I have forgotten my password

Register now

Activate my subscription

Institutional login

Athens login

close

About us

New Scientist

Syndication

Recruitment Advertising

Staff at New Scientist

Advertise

RBI Jobs

User Help

Contact Us

FAQ / Help

Disclaimer

Ts & Cs

Cookies

Privacy Policy

Subscriptions

Subscribe

Renew

Gift subscription

My account

Back issues

Customer Service

Links

Site Map

Browse all articles

Magazine archive

NewScientistJobs

The Last Word

RSS Feeds

Online Store

Android App

Low-bandwidth site

Science Jobs

Search all Jobs

Biology Jobs

Chemistry Jobs

Clinical Jobs

Earth & Environment Jobs

Engineering Jobs

Maths & IT Jobs

Careers Advice

© Copyright Reed Business Information Ltd.